Key Colony Beach Vacation Rentals

Compare 22 vacation rentals. Enter your trip dates to get started.
USA > Florida > Key Colony Beach

Make Key Colony Beach your next getaway—choose from 22 great vacation rentals

A palm tree paradise of white, sandy shores sloping gently into emerald green waters - your Key Colony Beach vacation rental will invoke supreme relaxation with its charming blend of laid-back attitudes and carefree, island vibes. Less than one-square-mile in size, Key Colony Beach is largely made up of upscale residential streets, a well-maintained public golf course, and palm tree-lined green spaces sandwiched between canals that provide direct access to the Atlantic Ocean.

Explore Key Colony Beach house rentals, duplexes, cottages, and more


House rentals

View 11 House rentals


View 10 Duplexes


View 1 Cottages

Key Colony Beach vacation rentals for every getaway

Dog-friendly Hot tub Internet
Life's a Breeze 3D Tour
3 Bed | 2 Bath | Sleeps 8

Life's a Breeze - Key Colony Beach, FL

From $512
Dock of the Bay 3D Tour
3 Bed | 2.5 Bath | Sleeps 6

Dock of the Bay - Key Colony Beach, FL

From $404
Comfort in the Keys 3D Tour
2 Bed | 2 Bath | Sleeps 4

Comfort in the Keys - Key Colony Beach, FL

From $136
Key Lime on Fifth Street 3D Tour
2 Bed | 2 Bath | Sleeps 4

Key Lime on Fifth Street - Key Colony Beach, FL

From $130
Casa de Rosa 3D Tour
4 Bed | 3 Bath | Sleeps 10

Casa de Rosa - Key Colony Beach, FL

From $482

View 17 more homes

Recent Key Colony Beach vacation rental reviews

We really enjoyed our stay at Captains haven! The location was excellent! The house was stocked with anything you need to have a wonderful vacation! Although the house could use some updates in the decor department it suited our needs traveling as 2 couples! We rented a boat for the week and we’re able to pull it right in in front of the unit! The neighbor next door was invaluable to us! He was so knowledgeable about the area he even sold us our lobsters for dinner ! Thanks for sharing your home with us!
Kandice D. | Sep 2021
The home was clean, spacious living room and easy to locate (road and dockside). I personally felt the beds were very comfortable, I slept great! Also, air conditioning units were helpful and kept it nice and cool at night. This is a great home to stay at if you’re going to be on the boat constantly, the dock outside is close to the home, not a long distance to bring gear or coolers out to. It has a hose ready and dock line. Although at low tide it is hard to get to the top of the dock if you don’t have a tower on your boat or ladder. But we did so no biggie. Canal is full of life! Manatees, fish, crab and pelicans that keep it fun to watch. All and all, great location and fits 4 people great!
Veronica W. | Aug 2021
We have stayed in this home twice. Both times were very nice. Great location, nice amenities.
Betty W. | Aug 2021

Book confidently. Stay comfortably.

Book confidently. Stay comfortably.
24/7 support
Easy check-in
Easy check-in
Professional cleaning
Professional cleaning

You won't find the nightlife of Miami Beach here, but for diving, snorkeling, fishing, and boating, this quaint beach burg can’t be beat. So book your own Key Colony Beach condo rental and start planning your next getaway for fun in the sun, sand, and surf!

Where are our Key Colony Beach vacation rentals?

Belonging to the sunny Florida Keys, this tiny island town lies on the east end of family-friendly Marathon. It is accessible via the Sadowski Causeway, which is connected to the Overseas Highway (U.S. Highway 1) that runs all the way to gorgeous Key West. We offer dozens of vacation homes throughout the Keys, and our condo and house rentals in Key Colony Beach are a great choice for anyone in search of the island life.

Things to do near your Key Colony Beach vacation rental

While relaxing beachside and stocking up on sunshine should be at the top of any Florida Keys vacationer’s list, those seeking other ways to get their vitamin D will find plenty more options at Key Colony Beach. Start your day off with a tee time for a full 18 holes at the picturesque Key Colony Beach Golf Course, or hop on a bike and peddle down the breezy Sadowski Causeway. Catch a midday snack at Sparky’s Landing (don’t forget to sample the delicious key lime pie) before heading back out to catch a few more rays and tranquil ocean views at Sunset Park.

Serious sport-fisherman and amateurs alike will rejoice in a number of options for reeling in record-size fish just offshore. Head out to the Atlantic with a knowledgeable guide aboard a local charter, and you’ll soon find the perfect conditions for landing a trophy marlin, bonefish, tarpon, or other native species inhabiting the local waters. If you're lucky, you might catch something delicious to cook up in your Key Colony Beach condo rental's kitchen.

Day trips from your Key Colony Beach rental

Just up the Overseas Highway, a trip to the rehabilitation facility and dolphin, seal, and manatee retirement home that is the Dolphin Research Center is sure to be hit with your kids. Swim alongside playful dolphins or feed fish to barking sea lions at this beloved non-profit. Your kids will squeal with delight upon every curious creature they encounter in interactive exhibits and tanks full of Florida-native sealife.

Kayak through lagoons and mangrove forests at Long Key State Park just 15 miles away, or lace up your hiking shoes and bring a pair of binoculars to spot rare native birds in their natural habitat. Bring a picnic to eat at the observation tower before heading back across the boardwalk, or come out here after sundown for stargazing under a dazzling night sky.

Pack your bags, grab plenty of sunscreen, and don’t forget your sense of adventure when you book a trip to one of our Key Colony Beach vacation rentals. Whether you’ve come for relaxation or recreation, rest assured you’ll find it all just steps from your door in one of our beach house or condo rentals in Key Colony Beach.

Discover Key Colony Beach

4 Florida Keys Races and Marathons for Every Skill Level